What is Moneyball Actually
2026/10/27
It’s not a 2011 movie starring Brad Pitt and Jonah Hill, it’s not letting Scott Hatteberg play first base, and it’s not even about getting on base. It’s about being TRENDY
(there’s a youtube video that foolish bailey released today that’s exactly on this topic but i swear i was thinking about it before he published it link)
For the longest time (20 years), old baseball fudds have complained that ‘Moneyball’ and ‘Analytics’ have ruined baseball. They use these terms interchangeably because they don’t understand or appreciate the value of having granular words to distinguish between nuanced concepts. Which is ironic, because they’re bemoaning the loss of nuance in baseball when they complain that no one bats .300 anymore.
Unfortunately, those boomers are right. The subjects of that Brad Pitt movie, the 2002 Oakland Athletics, set a trend of picking up undervalued baseball players who suck at defense, but walk a lot and hit homers. It turns out, sucking at defense is ugly and walking is boring. Homers are still cool, but most home run hitters are spending half of their at-bats striking out (ugly) or walking (as established before, boring). The monetarily-challenged A’s found this cheap, ugly yet effective way to win baseball games; and the rich teams, as the rich are wont to do, ripped off the style of the poors and ruined it for everyone.
But what is beautiful baseball? What is it that the oldheads are missing from modern baseball? It’s guys putting the ball in play. It’s making the fielders have to make a play. It’s bunting, and stealing bases, and rolling around in the dirt.
“Thats fucking baseball right there. None of that pansy ass dick tugging smile for the camera bullshit. Men puke, men poop on the field, men deliver their new born baby in the dugouts. Fucking hard core dick in the ass butterball foosball fuck it chuck it game time shit. Take it to the showers. Dicks get shoved in places you don’t even remember. We win together we celebrate together. Baseball is back baby.” -unattributable
The Oakland A’s broke everyone’s minds so hard that the beautiful ballplayers who were overvalued in the early 2000s are now the undervalued true Moneyball darlings. Looking at this year’s World Series matchup, we have two iconic Moneyball (read: poor) teams: the Tampa Bay Rays and the Milwaukee Brewers. These guys are playing beautiful baseball. They bunt and steal more than any other team. They haven’t completely eschewed power and on-base skills, but they aren’t completely optimized towards those skill sets like before. The Rays are starting Chandler Simpson, a guy who spent the 2026 season hitting 0 home runs, stealing 46 bases, and batting .306. Not since 1999 has a player batted over .300 with zero home runs throughout a complete season (Luis Castillo).
Moneyball was never about finding the optimal strategy for building a baseball team, it was about finding the optimal strategy for building a baseball team given strict budgetary constraints.
Let’s pray the Rays and Brewers are setting the trend for fashionable baseball for the next 20 years. Let’s toss away the matcha lattes and wired headphones of our performative-male big budget baseball teams and let’s welcome in our blue-collar, on-field-pooping real man baseball teams.