On Numerical Ratings

last updated 2026/10/28

On a scale of negative seven to one billion, tell me how your day was. That’s you. That’s how you sound when you ask me to put a number on how good a movie is.

First off, no two people have the same conception of what a 4/5 movie is. If you don’t know me, you have no idea what I mean when I give Rocky Horror Picture Show 5 stars on Letterboxd. That movie is trash. If you do know me, you can just TALK to me and get an idea of what I thought of a movie. Failing that, you can read what I write about the movie (here or in my shitpost Letterboxd reviews) and infer how much I enjoyed the movie.

Are you even expecting my number rating to be an objective measure of the quality of the movie or just a measure of how much I enjoyed it? I’ve never been consistent with how each of those weigh into my final score, and I doubt you have either. Like, really, find me two movies you rated the same and breakdown for me why they got the same score.

And what is wrong with people who are putting non-0.5 decimals in their movie scores. What the fuck do you mean you rated Boondock Saints a 6.9/10. I can understand a 6.5, you already can’t decide between 10 points of precision (far too many already) for how good a movie is, so you split the difference between two of those points. But where is that 0.9 coming from? Where are you finding a 1% margin in how good Boondock Saints is that you can give it a 6.9 instead of a flat 7 or a 6.8?

The answer is that the numbers are meaningless. You either like a movie or you don’t, you’d either recommend a movie or you wouldn’t. What are you doing with yourself that you’re too busy to read a review, but you still want to know that reviewer’s rating for a movie? If you cared, you’d read the review, at which point that number means infinitely less than the WORDS they used to describe their experience.

I rate rating movies out of ten a six point seven out of ten, it has a little bit for everyone.